Update – 06-Aug-2010
This post was inaccurate, in that it failed to acknowledge that Microsoft.Data supports parameters in its text querying. I have made changes to address this inaccuracy.
What is it?
It’s a very lightweight data access framework that I wouldn’t dream of calling an ORM. It uses the dynamic features of Microsoft .NET 4 to provide very expressive ways of retrieving data. It provides non-SQL ways of doing things, inspired by the Ruby ActiveRecord library. It also provides SQL ways of doing things, but with features to protect against SQL injection.
Because Microsoft have identified a gap in the data access toolkit ecosystem which they think scares casual web developers who are used to environments like PHP. These developers neither want nor need a full-blown ORM like NHibernate or Entity Framework, and they don’t want to deal with the complexity of ADO.NET connections, commands and readers.
Microsoft have recently released a preview of a new library, Microsoft.Data.dll, which aims to serve these developers. It provides various simple ways of opening up a database, and then lets you run SQL against it, which is how casual developers are used to working with MySQL in the PHP world. They build up their SQL strings and then they execute them.
The problem is, that’s wrong. And I believe that attempting to attract people to your stack by giving them a really easy way to carry on doing things wrong is also wrong. The right thing to do is give them a way to do things right that is as easy as, if not easier than, what they have been using.
Simple.Data is my attempt at that.
Using Microsoft.Data, you
would should query a Users table like this:
var db = Database.Open(); // Connection specified in config. string sql = "select * from users where name = @0 and password = @1"; var user = db.Query(sql, name, password).FirstOrDefault();
But you could query it like this:
var db = Database.Open(); // Connection specified in config. string sql = "select * from users where name = '" + name + "' and password = '" password + "'"; var user = db.Query(sql).FirstOrDefault();
A lot of people are quite cross about this. One of the main problems they have is that building query strings in this way opens your application up to SQL injection attacks. This is a common pattern in PHP applications written by new developers.
To achieve the same task with Simple.Data, you can do this:
var db = Database.Open(); // Connection specified in config. var user = db.Users.FindByNameAndPassword(name, password);
That’s pretty neat, right? So, did we have to generate the Database class and a bunch of table classes to make this work?
In this example, the type returned by Database.Open() is dynamic. It doesn’t have a Users property, but when that property is referenced on it, it returns a new instance of a DynamicTable type, again as dynamic. That instance doesn’t actually have a method called FindByNameAndPassword, but when it’s called, it sees “FindBy” at the start of the method, so it pulls apart the rest of the method name, combines it with the arguments, and builds an ADO.NET command which safely encapsulates the name and password values inside parameters. The FindBy* methods will only return one record; there are FindAllBy* methods which return result sets. This approach is used by the Ruby/Rails ActiveRecord library; Ruby’s metaprogramming nature encourages stuff like this.
[A section which wrongly implied that Microsoft.Data did not support parameterized queries has been removed here.]
Inserting using named parameters:
db.Users.Insert(Name: "Steve", Password: "Secret", Age: 21);
Executing an update:
db.Execute("update Stock set Current = Current - 1 where ProductId = ?", productId);
(Planned) inserting/updating using an object:
This project is more of a constructive criticism of Microsoft’s preview than anything else. I’m going to develop it a bit further (for example, the “planned” syntax support above), mainly as an exercise. One thing I’d maybe like to explore further is whether it can be used as a layer over NoSQL stores as well as RDBMS.
The project is hosted at http://github.com/markrendle/Simple.Data for anybody who wants to download and play with it.
I’d really appreciate feedback, so please do use the comments if you’ve got any criticisms, suggestions or encouragement to express.